I prefer Noah Rye of the names you have listed.

Have you considered Noah Asher, though?
I think it has a nice ring to it.

Noah Asher is a cute name! But I would have the first name as Naah. Noah and Jakob sound good together.

I really like Rye Asher or Asher Rye. Not only does Asher mean happy it also means blessed. I'm a preacher's kid and we just recently did a study on the meaning of Asher at our church camp. I love the name. I'm also with everyone else on the name Rye, if you and your husband love it then name him Rye. Yes family's opinions are important, but it's ultimately your decision.

I like Noah Rye

I like Rye Asher. I think its a lovely name and a name you and your husband love which is all that matters.

I like Rye but it sort of seems like it could be a girls name? How about Ryeko/Rycoh and call him Rye? Out of your names I would go for Noah Rye. Good luck!! And remember that it's your decision and don't feel pressured into a name that you don't love 100%